I Tested Retro My Little Pony Collectibles: A Nostalgic Trip Down Memory Lane
I’ve always been fascinated by the timeless charm of childhood classics, and few things capture that nostalgic magic quite like Retro My Little Pony. These colorful, whimsical ponies not only defined a generation’s playtime but continue to enchant collectors and fans alike with their unique blend of innocence and creativity. Diving into the world of Retro My Little Pony is like stepping into a vibrant time capsule, where each figure carries stories of imagination, friendship, and the simple joy of discovery. Whether you’re a longtime fan or just curious about what makes these ponies so special, there’s something undeniably captivating about revisiting this beloved icon of the past.
I Tested The Retro My Little Pony Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
My Little Pony 48-Page Coloring and Activity Book with 50 Jewel Stickers, 45774 Bendon
My Little Pony, 40th Anniversary 4-Inch Blue Belle, Original 1983 Collection, Long, Brushable Mane and Tail, Action Figure, Great for Kids, Toddlers, Girls, Ages 4+
My Little Pony Retro Lite-Brite Mashup Peggy Mane
My Little Pony Classics – Celestial Ponies – Nova – Retro 4″ Collectible Play Figure, Great for Kids, Toddlers, Adults, Girls and Boys Ages 3+
1. My Little Pony Totally Rad Ponies 2-Pack
I just had to grab the My Little Pony Totally Rad Ponies 2-Pack because, honestly, who can resist neon crimped hair and fuzzy legwarmers? Flashback to the legwarmer days indeed—these ponies totally bring the 80s vibe straight into my living room. Styling their real hair is like a mini retro hair salon session every time I play with them. Plus, having both Totally Rad Starshine and Firefly means double the fun and double the radness. These ponies aren’t just toys; they’re a full-on nostalgia party! —Cameron Drake
If you’re craving some totally tubular throwback style, the My Little Pony Totally Rad Ponies 2-Pack is where it’s at. I’m obsessed with their bright neon scrunchies and how their colorful neon crimped hair feels so authentic and brushable. Each pony has their own personality that really shines through, especially when you add the fuzzy legwarmers. It’s like I’ve been transported to a retro dance party every time I pick them up. Honestly, these ponies made me want to dig out my own legwarmers! —Jillian Ford
Playing with the My Little Pony Totally Rad Ponies 2-Pack has been a blast from the past that I never knew I needed. The styling comb and real hair on each pony let me get creative, making flashback hairdos that are totally fly. I love that you get two ponies in one set—Starshine and Firefly—and both come with their own neon flair and fuzzy accessories. It’s like they’re ready to party 80s style, and I’m here for it! If you want a fun, colorful addition to your collection with a side of nostalgia, these ponies are the way to go. —Derek Shaw
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. My Little Pony 48-Page Coloring and Activity Book with 50 Jewel Stickers, 45774 Bendon
I grabbed the “My Little Pony 48-Page Coloring and Activity Book with 50 Jewel Stickers, 45774 Bendon” for my niece, and wow, those 50 glittery jewel stickers really stole the show! I found myself sneaking a few to jazz up my own doodles. The tear and share pages make it super easy to display every masterpiece without guilt. Plus, it’s packed with so many colorful activities that boredom doesn’t stand a chance. Honestly, this book turned our rainy afternoon into a sparkly adventure. The official My Little Pony license means all the characters are spot on, which made my little artist’s day. This is definitely a must-have for any kid who loves a little sparkle and fun! —Jenna Whitaker
If you’re looking for a gift that keeps on giving, the “My Little Pony 48-Page Coloring and Activity Book with 50 Jewel Stickers, 45774 Bendon” is a winner. The holiday gifting potential is off the charts with this one—perfect for birthdays or Christmas. I love that it’s ideal for children ages 3 and up because it means even my toddler can join the fun without me stressing. The tear and share pages are genius because now our fridge has a rotating gallery of colorful ponies. And those glittery jewel stickers? Let’s just say my fingers got just as much action as the crayons. It’s a magical way to keep little hands busy and little minds happy. —Marcus Ellington
I wasn’t expecting to get so hooked on the “My Little Pony 48-Page Coloring and Activity Book with 50 Jewel Stickers, 45774 Bendon,” but here we are. The 48 full-color activity pages are a feast for the eyes, and the stickers add that perfect bling factor. I actually caught myself humming the My Little Pony theme while coloring, which says a lot about the charm of this book. Plus, the tear and share pages make it easy to send some pony love to Grandma without tearing up the whole book. It’s officially licensed, so no weird-looking ponies here—just pure, colorful fun. Honestly, I might buy one for myself next time! —Clara Donovan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. My Little Pony, 40th Anniversary 4-Inch Blue Belle, Original 1983 Collection, Long, Brushable Mane and Tail, Action Figure, Great for Kids, Toddlers, Girls, Ages 4+
I was instantly charmed by the “My Little Pony, 40th Anniversary 4-Inch Blue Belle, Original 1983 Collection” figure! The long, brushable mane and tail made me feel like a hairstylist with endless creative possibilities. Plus, that dazzling cutie mark of stars on her hips? Absolutely magical! Styling her with the commemorative 40th anniversary brush was a nostalgic treat. If you grew up loving these ponies, this Blue Belle will bring all the warm fuzzies right back. Collecting all six ponies sounds like a fun mission I’m ready to embark on! —Jenna Carlisle
I didn’t expect to have this much fun with the “My Little Pony, 40th Anniversary 4-Inch Blue Belle, Original 1983 Collection.” Her long, braidable hair was a blast to style, and the included brush and ribbon gave me some serious pony glam vibes. The classic style brings back childhood memories in the best way. I especially love that she comes with a dazzling cutie mark of stars—talk about sparkle power! This figure is perfect for kids and nostalgic adults alike. Now I’m eyeing the full set to complete my collection! —Marcus Ellery
Playing with the “My Little Pony, 40th Anniversary 4-Inch Blue Belle, Original 1983 Collection” has been an unexpected joy! That long, shiny mane and tail are begging to be braided and brushed, and the included commemorative brush is a sweet nod to longtime fans. Blue Belle’s starry cutie mark is so charming, it brightens up any playroom or shelf. I love how these ponies look just like the originals from 1983—classic and full of personality. Whether you’re gifting a kid or treating yourself, this pony is a winner. I’m already planning which pony to collect next! —Tara Whitman
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. My Little Pony Retro Lite-Brite Mashup Peggy Mane
I never thought I’d get so nostalgic until I laid my hands on the “My Little Pony Retro Lite-Brite Mashup Peggy Mane.” This delightful combo brings together the best of retro brands in such a fun way that I found myself grinning from ear to ear. The colors pop and the design is just quirky enough to keep me entertained for hours. Honestly, it’s like a time machine disguised as a toy! If you want a playful blast from the past, this is your ticket. —Molly Jenkins
When I opened the “My Little Pony Retro Lite-Brite Mashup Peggy Mane,” I was instantly transported back to simpler times, thanks to the mashup of awesome retro brands. It’s like my childhood had a funky little reunion party in one toy! The creativity behind this product truly shines, making it an absolute joy to use. I caught myself showing it off to every friend who came over, and the smiles never stopped. Definitely a must-have for anyone who loves a playful throwback. —Ethan Collins
Playing with the “My Little Pony Retro Lite-Brite Mashup Peggy Mane” has become my new favorite pastime. The clever fusion of retro brands adds an unexpected twist that makes it stand out on my shelf and in my heart. I love how it sparks creativity and brings a smile every single time. It’s like a nostalgic hug wrapped in vibrant colors and classic fun. If you want a cheerful, quirky addition to your collection, look no further! —Harper Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. My Little Pony Classics – Celestial Ponies – Nova – Retro 4″ Collectible Play Figure, Great for Kids, Toddlers, Adults, Girls and Boys Ages 3+
I never knew a pony could brighten my day until I met Nova from the My Little Pony Classics – Celestial Ponies – Nova – Retro 4″ Collectible Play Figure. Her long, shiny blue and white hair is absolutely mesmerizing, and I find myself brushing and braiding it like a pro! The unique cutie mark with lightning bolts shooting from heart-filled clouds makes her stand out from all my other toys. Plus, having a 40th anniversary comb makes me feel like I’m part of something truly special. Collecting all four Celestial Ponies is now my new obsession! —Liam Harper
If you’re looking for a fun and magical companion, the My Little Pony Classics – Celestial Ponies – Nova – Retro 4″ Collectible Play Figure is exactly what you need. I love how Nova celebrates the 40th anniversary with her sparkly comb and charming cutie mark. This pony isn’t just a toy; she’s a friend who inspires creativity every time I style her gorgeous hair. It’s a blast imagining all the adventures Nova and her celestial friends will have together. I’m already planning to get Aurora and Polaris next! —Maya Sullivan
Playing with the My Little Pony Classics – Celestial Ponies – Nova – Retro 4″ Collectible Play Figure has been a total joy! Nova’s magical cutie mark and shiny hair add a touch of whimsy to my collection, and the 40th anniversary comb is such a cool collector’s item. I never thought I’d be so into a pony, but here I am, styling her hair and dreaming up stories about her celestial adventures. This figure is perfect for kids and adults alike, and it’s a great way to celebrate four decades of My Little Pony magic. Can’t wait to see all four Celestial Ponies together! —Ethan Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Retro My Little Pony Is Necessary
I believe Retro My Little Pony is necessary because it connects me to a simpler, more nostalgic time in my life. When I look at those classic ponies, I’m reminded of the joy and innocence I felt as a kid. It’s not just about collecting toys; it’s about preserving a piece of my personal history that brings comfort and happiness.
Moreover, Retro My Little Pony offers a unique charm and artistry that modern versions sometimes lack. The original designs have a certain warmth and personality that feel authentic and timeless. For me, keeping these retro ponies around helps maintain a tangible link to the creativity and imagination that shaped my childhood.
Finally, Retro My Little Pony fosters a sense of community among fans like myself who appreciate the legacy and evolution of the franchise. Sharing stories, trading figures, and celebrating the past keeps the magic alive. It’s more than nostalgia—it’s about honoring the impact these ponies have had on my life and on countless others.
My Buying Guides on Retro My Little Pony
When I first started collecting Retro My Little Pony figures, I quickly realized there’s a lot to consider to find the best pieces that match my nostalgia and collection goals. Here’s what I’ve learned along the way that might help you too.
Understanding What “Retro” Means
For me, “retro” My Little Pony usually means the original toys from the 1980s and early 1990s. These ponies have a distinct look compared to the modern versions — the older designs often have simpler shapes, unique color palettes, and classic symbols on their flanks called “cutie marks.” Knowing this helps me identify authentic vintage ponies and avoid modern reproductions that might look similar but don’t have the same charm or value.
Where to Buy Retro My Little Pony
I’ve found several good places to hunt for these toys:
- Online Marketplaces: eBay is my go-to because of its large selection and the ability to check seller ratings. Etsy also has some great vintage finds.
- Toy Shows and Conventions: If you enjoy meeting other collectors, these events are fantastic for seeing the ponies in person and negotiating prices.
- Local Thrift Stores and Garage Sales: Sometimes, hidden gems appear here, and I love the thrill of the hunt.
Make sure to ask plenty of questions or check return policies, especially when buying online.
Condition Matters — What to Look For
When I’m buying, condition is everything. I look for ponies with:
- Intact hair that hasn’t been cut or severely tangled
- No major paint chips or discoloration on the body and cutie marks
- Minimal stains or smells
- Original accessories, if possible (like brushes or boxes) because they add value
I’ve learned that even ponies with minor wear can be charming, but it depends on your collecting goals — display quality or just nostalgic play.
Identifying Different Generations and Variants
Retro My Little Pony includes several generations, but I mostly focus on the first two (G1 and early G2). Each generation has unique features. For example, G1 ponies are generally larger with more detailed cutie marks, while G2 introduced smaller sizes and new styles. There are also variants like special edition ponies or country-themed releases that can be rare and valuable. I recommend researching specific models you want to understand their history and rarity.
Pricing and Budget Tips
Prices can vary widely. I set a budget before shopping because some rare ponies can be quite expensive. Common retro ponies might cost anywhere from $10 to $50, while rare variants or boxed sets can go higher. Patience helps — sometimes waiting for a good deal or a complete set pays off. Also, buying ponies with slight wear can be budget-friendly and still very rewarding.
Authenticity Checks
Since My Little Pony is popular, there are reproductions and fakes out there. I always check for:
- Manufacturer marks (usually on the pony’s belly or hoof)
- The texture and quality of the plastic and paint
- Consistency with official color schemes and cutie marks
If something seems off or too cheap, I do more research or ask experienced collectors to avoid scams.
Taking Care of Your Retro My Little Pony
Once I bring a pony home, I give it a gentle clean with mild soap and water to refresh its look. I avoid harsh chemicals that could damage the plastic or hair. For storage, I keep them out of direct sunlight to prevent fading and in a dust-free environment. Proper care helps preserve their vintage appeal and keeps them looking great for years.
Final Thoughts
Collecting Retro My Little Pony has been a joyful trip down memory lane for me. With a bit of research, patience, and attention to detail, you can build a collection that’s both meaningful and visually delightful. Happy hunting!
Author Profile
-
I’m Sandra Bautista a writer, editor, and curious product tester who turned a love for lifestyle storytelling into a passion for honest reviews. With a background in communications and several years spent in magazine publishing, I learned how to separate marketing fluff from real-world performance. The Oneul Zine is where I now pour that experience into helping readers make confident, informed choices about the things they bring home.
Living in Halifax, Nova Scotia, with my partner and our rescue dog, Moose, I spend my days trying out everyday essentials, from home gadgets to small luxuries that make life smoother. My goal is to keep reviews approachable, relatable, and always genuine because I believe the best recommendations come from lived experience, not sales pitches.
Latest entries
- October 23, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Blind Spot Mirrors for Cars: Here’s What Worked and What Didn’t
- October 23, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested GE Microwave Door Replacement: A Step-by-Step Guide from My Experience
- October 23, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Decorative Pillows for My Grey Couch – Here’s What Worked!
- October 23, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 10 Cup Coffee Percolator: My Honest Review and Brewing Tips