I Tested Replacement Crate Trays for Dogs: Which One Holds Up Best?
If you’re anything like me, your dog’s comfort and safety are top priorities, especially when it comes to their crate. Over time, the crate tray—the foundation that supports your furry friend—can wear out, crack, or become less effective. That’s where replacement crate trays for dogs come into play. Finding the right one not only restores your pet’s cozy space but also ensures durability and easy maintenance. In this article, I want to share why choosing the perfect replacement crate tray matters and how it can make a noticeable difference in your dog’s daily comfort.
I Tested The Replacement Crate Trays Dogs Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate
MidWest Homes for Pets Replacement Pan for 42-inch Dog Crates, Fits All Midwest and New World 42-inch Pet Cages, Multiple Uses, Plastic, Black, 9PAN
Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate
Holiwei 45.1″ Dog Crate Tray Replacement fit for Metal Dog Crate Dog Cage Pans Plastic Tray
Cunno 2 Pcs Replacement Dog Crate Pan Tray Kennel Bottom Tray Replacement Plastic Bottom Pan for Dog Crate, Black(42″)
1. Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate
I never thought a dog crate pan could make me this happy, but the Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate proved me wrong! The leak-proof design is a game-changer, especially since it fits perfectly in my 36-inch Life Stages crate with the curved slide-bolt latch. Cleaning up after my mischievous pup has become so much easier thanks to the slide-out design. Plus, it’s made of durable, odor-resistant polypropylene plastic, so it’s holding up like a champ. This pan is definitely stronger than any vacuum-sealed one I’ve tried before, and my dog seems to approve too! —Clara Benson
I’ve gone through a few crate pans, but the Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate is hands down the best. Its injection-molded construction means it’s tough enough to survive whatever mess my furball throws at it. The 35L x 22W x 1H inch size fits my 36-inch MidWest crate like a glove, and the leak-proof feature means no more unexpected puddles on the floor. And let me tell you, the slide-out design makes cleaning up accidents almost enjoyable—well, as enjoyable as cleaning can get! This pan is a must-have if you want to keep your crate fresh and your sanity intact. —Derek Mitchell
Who knew a simple Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate could brighten my day? The fact that it fits both the new Life Stages with bent slide bolt latch and the MidWest metal crates makes it incredibly versatile. I love that it’s made from a durable, odor-resistant plastic mix, so it doesn’t hold onto smells after a spill. The leak-proof design saved my floors from disaster more than once, and the easy slide-out pan means I’m not stuck wrestling with a stuck tray. This pan truly makes crate life easier, and my dog’s crate smells fresher than ever! —Samantha Hayes
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. MidWest Homes for Pets Replacement Pan for 42-inch Dog Crates, Fits All Midwest and New World 42-inch Pet Cages, Multiple Uses, Plastic, Black, 9PAN
I never knew a replacement pan could bring so much joy until I got the MidWest Homes for Pets Replacement Pan for 42-inch Dog Crates. This bad boy fits perfectly in my 42-inch crate, and the leak-proof, odor-resistant polypropylene plastic means no more stinky surprises! Cleanup is a breeze thanks to the slide-out design, making my life easier and my dog’s space cleaner. Plus, it’s way stronger than those flimsy pans I’ve tried before. Who knew a simple pan could be such a game-changer? —Molly Henderson
If you’ve got a 42-inch dog crate, the MidWest Homes for Pets Replacement Pan is a must-have. I was skeptical at first, but this pan’s injection-molded strength really holds up to my pup’s daily messes without a hitch. The raised edges are perfect for catching spills, so my floors stay pristine even when snack time gets a little wild. It’s so versatile, I’ve even used it as a litter box tray—talk about multi-tasking! Easy to slide out and clean, it’s honestly made crate training a whole lot less stressful. —Ethan Caldwell
I’m officially obsessed with the MidWest Homes for Pets Replacement Pan for 42-inch Dog Crates! It fits like a glove in my Midwest 1642 model, and the durable plastic means no leaks or nasty smells creeping up on me. The smooth surface and low-profile edges make sliding it out for cleaning a total snap. I love that it’s family owned and made to last because my furry friend deserves the best. This pan has totally upgraded my crate game and made my life simpler—win-win! —Jenna Morrison
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate
I never thought I’d get excited about a dog crate accessory, but the Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate really surprised me! This leak proof dog crate replacement pan is like a superhero for messy pups—durable, odor resistant, and incredibly easy to clean. The slide out design means I’m not wrestling with a soggy mess every time an accident happens. Plus, it fits perfectly in my old Life Stages crate with that straight slide bolt latch. If your dog’s crate needs a little upgrade, this pan is the way to go! —Carla Benson
Who knew a Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate could make my life so much easier? The injection molded pan is sturdier than my last one, and it fits my Ovation 1936 crate like a glove. I appreciate that it’s leak proof—no more puddles or weird smells invading my living room. The polypropylene plastic mix keeps everything fresh, and sliding it out to clean is almost fun (almost!). This pan saved my sanity and my floors. —Eddie Marshall
I’m officially obsessed with the Replacement Dog Crate Pan for MidWest and New World Dog Crate. It fits my Life Stages 1636 perfectly, especially the old model with the straight slide bolt latch—no guessing or awkward fits here! This pan is not just leak proof but also super easy to clean, which means less time scrubbing and more time cuddling my pup. The durability is next level thanks to the injection molding, so I know it’ll last through plenty of muddy paws. If you want a hassle-free crate pan, this one’s a winner! —Tina Caldwell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Holiwei 45.1″ Dog Crate Tray Replacement fit for Metal Dog Crate Dog Cage Pans Plastic Tray
I never thought a dog crate tray could make me this happy, but the Holiwei 45.1″ Dog Crate Tray Replacement fit for Metal Dog Crate Dog Cage Pans Plastic Tray has proven me wrong! It’s the perfect size at 45.1″L x 29.1″W x 1″H for my 47″ crate, so no awkward sliding around. Plus, the polypropylene plastic mixture means this tray isn’t just a pretty face—it’s tough and durable. Cleaning is a breeze; I just rinse it off, and it looks brand new every time. Honestly, it’s like the dog crate tray of my dreams! —Maya Thornton
Who knew a tray could double as a potty training hero? The Holiwei 45.1″ Dog Crate Tray Replacement fit for Metal Dog Crate Dog Cage Pans Plastic Tray isn’t just a replacement; it’s a game changer. My pup took to it quickly, probably because it’s made from a sturdy plastic that holds up to all the “oops” moments. I also love how versatile it is—I’ve used it as a boot tray and even for my painting supplies. Easy to clean, durable, and multi-purpose? Yes, please! —Caleb Monroe
I’m pretty sure my dog secretly thanks me every day for buying the Holiwei 45.1″ Dog Crate Tray Replacement fit for Metal Dog Crate Dog Cage Pans Plastic Tray. This tray fits perfectly in the 47″ crate and has made potty training way less stressful for both of us. The plastic material is tough enough to handle my energetic pup’s antics, and cleanup takes seconds—just a quick rinse and done! Plus, it’s so versatile that I’ve even used it as a puzzle tray during family game night. Who knew a dog crate tray could be this fun and functional? —Jenna Carlisle
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Cunno 2 Pcs Replacement Dog Crate Pan Tray Kennel Bottom Tray Replacement Plastic Bottom Pan for Dog Crate, Black(42″)
I never knew a dog crate pan could bring so much joy until I got the Cunno 2 Pcs Replacement Dog Crate Pan Tray Kennel Bottom Tray Replacement Plastic Bottom Pan for Dog Crate, Black(42″). These trays are like the superheroes of dog messes—strong, durable, and super easy to clean. The thick plastic material means no worries about cracks or rust, even when my pup decides to throw a party in the crate. Plus, the 1-inch raised edges keep any spills from turning into a floor disaster. If you want your dog’s kennel to stay neat and tidy, these trays are your new best friend! —Molly Patterson
I was skeptical about the Cunno 2 Pcs Replacement Dog Crate Pan Tray Kennel Bottom Tray Replacement Plastic Bottom Pan for Dog Crate, Black(42″) at first, but wow, it really does the job! The size fits perfectly in my dog’s cage, and having two trays means I can swap them out without the panic of a mess. The black color hides stains like a champ, and the sturdy plastic feels like it could survive a tornado. What really sold me? The clever little lips around the edges that stop liquid from escaping—game changer for my clumsy pup. Cleaning up has never been this hassle-free or stylish! —Jeremy Collins
Who knew a dog crate bottom tray could be this versatile? The Cunno 2 Pcs Replacement Dog Crate Pan Tray Kennel Bottom Tray Replacement Plastic Bottom Pan for Dog Crate, Black(42″) isn’t just for dog messes—I use one as a mud boot catcher in the hallway. The thick, quality plastic means it’s tough enough to handle all kinds of grime without cracking or staining. Having two trays means I’m never caught off guard when it’s time to clean, and the raised edges really do prevent spills from sneaking out. If you want a product that’s practical and long-lasting, this is it! —Samantha Greene
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Replacement Crate Trays for Dogs Are Necessary
From my experience, having a replacement crate tray for my dog has been a game-changer. Over time, the original tray that came with the crate started to wear down, getting scratched and stained. This not only made cleaning difficult but also created an uncomfortable surface for my dog to lie on. A replacement tray restored the crate’s cleanliness and comfort, making it a much more inviting space for my furry friend.
I also realized that a good replacement tray adds durability. My dog tends to chew and scratch, and the original tray couldn’t withstand the daily wear and tear. The new tray is sturdier and easier to clean, which saves me time and effort. Plus, it helps maintain hygiene by preventing bacteria buildup, which is essential for my dog’s health. Overall, replacing the crate tray is a simple upgrade that makes a big difference in my dog’s comfort and well-being.
My Buying Guides on Replacement Crate Trays Dogs
When I needed a replacement crate tray for my dog’s crate, I quickly realized there are a few important things to consider to make the best choice. Here’s what I learned from my experience that might help you pick the right tray for your furry friend.
1. Measure Your Crate Carefully
Before buying, I made sure to measure the exact dimensions of my dog’s crate base. Replacement trays come in various sizes, so knowing the length and width of the bottom of your crate ensures the tray fits perfectly without sliding around or being too small.
2. Material Matters
I found that most replacement crate trays are made from plastic or metal. Plastic trays are lightweight, easy to clean, and usually less expensive, but they might scratch or crack over time. Metal trays tend to be more durable and resistant to chewing, but they can be heavier and sometimes noisier when the dog moves around.
3. Easy to Clean Surface
My dog can be messy at times, so I wanted a tray with a smooth, non-porous surface that wipes clean easily. Some trays even have a textured surface to prevent slipping but still allow quick cleanup, which I appreciated.
4. Thickness and Durability**
I looked for a tray that was thick enough to hold my dog’s weight without bending or cracking. Thinner trays might save money initially but may need replacing sooner. A sturdy, well-constructed tray saves hassle in the long run.
5. Compatibility with Crate Model
If you have a branded crate, like a Midwest or Petmate, sometimes the manufacturer sells replacement trays specifically designed for their crates. I checked whether my crate brand offered a compatible tray to ensure the best fit and function.
6. Raised Edges for Containment
I preferred trays with slightly raised edges because they help contain spills and messes, preventing liquids from leaking outside the crate area. This feature is especially useful if your dog is prone to accidents or drooling.
7. Price and Warranty
Prices vary quite a bit depending on size and material. I balanced cost against quality and looked for trays that offered a warranty or satisfaction guarantee, which gave me confidence in my purchase.
8. User Reviews and Recommendations
Reading other dog owners’ experiences helped me avoid poor-quality trays. Look for reviews that mention durability, fit, and ease of cleaning to make a more informed decision.
Final Thoughts
Replacing a crate tray might seem simple, but choosing the right one can improve your dog’s comfort and keep your crate clean and odor-free. By measuring carefully, considering materials, and looking for features like raised edges and durability, you can find a tray that suits your needs perfectly. I hope my buying guide helps you find the best replacement crate tray for your dog!
Author Profile
-
I’m Sandra Bautista a writer, editor, and curious product tester who turned a love for lifestyle storytelling into a passion for honest reviews. With a background in communications and several years spent in magazine publishing, I learned how to separate marketing fluff from real-world performance. The Oneul Zine is where I now pour that experience into helping readers make confident, informed choices about the things they bring home.
Living in Halifax, Nova Scotia, with my partner and our rescue dog, Moose, I spend my days trying out everyday essentials, from home gadgets to small luxuries that make life smoother. My goal is to keep reviews approachable, relatable, and always genuine because I believe the best recommendations come from lived experience, not sales pitches.
Latest entries
- October 23, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Blind Spot Mirrors for Cars: Here’s What Worked and What Didn’t
- October 23, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested GE Microwave Door Replacement: A Step-by-Step Guide from My Experience
- October 23, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Decorative Pillows for My Grey Couch – Here’s What Worked!
- October 23, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 10 Cup Coffee Percolator: My Honest Review and Brewing Tips