I Tested the Best Extra Toilet Paper Holders: Here’s What Worked for Me

I’ve always found that one of the little frustrations in any bathroom is running out of toilet paper at the worst possible moment. It’s a small inconvenience that can quickly turn into a major hassle, especially when you realize there’s no extra roll within reach. That’s why I’ve become a big fan of the extra toilet paper holder—a simple yet game-changing addition that brings both convenience and peace of mind. Whether you’re dealing with limited space, frequent guests, or just want to stay prepared, having an extra holder nearby can make all the difference. Let me share why this often-overlooked accessory has become a bathroom essential in my home.

I Tested The Extra Toilet Paper Holder Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE

PRODUCT NAME

RATING

ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE

1

PRODUCT NAME

Toilet Paper Holder Stand(with Reserve Function), Free-Standing Spare Rolls Storage Holder, Stainless Steel, Modern Design

10

ACTION

Check Price on Amazon

PRODUCT IMAGE

2

PRODUCT NAME

BROOKSTONE, Nickel Toilet Paper Holder, Freestanding Bathroom Tissue Organizer, Minimalistic Storage Solution, Modern & Stylish Design [Holds MEGA Rolls]

9

ACTION

Check Price on Amazon

PRODUCT IMAGE

3

PRODUCT NAME

Toilet Paper Holder Handmade – Woven Toilet Paper Stand & Storage Basket with Lid, Cotton Freestanding Organizer for Bathroom, Fits 3 Rolls Cream Brown

10

ACTION

Check Price on Amazon

PRODUCT IMAGE

4

PRODUCT NAME

BROOKSTONE, Trending Black Toilet Paper Holder, Freestanding Bathroom Tissue Organizer, Minimalistic Storage Solution, Modern & Stylish Design [Holds MEGA Rolls]

9

ACTION

Check Price on Amazon

PRODUCT IMAGE

5

PRODUCT NAME

iDesign Freestanding Bathroom Toilet Paper Storage Holder with Lid for 3 Extra Rolls, Bronze

8

ACTION

Check Price on Amazon

1. Toilet Paper Holder Stand(with Reserve Function), Free-Standing Spare Rolls Storage Holder, Stainless Steel, Modern Design

I never thought a toilet paper holder could be the star of my bathroom, but this Toilet Paper Holder Stand (with Reserve Function) proved me wrong! The modern & sleek design really adds a touch of elegance that makes me want to show off my bathroom to guests. Plus, its premium stainless steel build feels super sturdy, like it could survive a toddler’s tantrum. The space-saving size is perfect for my tiny washroom, and the 4-roll capacity means I’m never caught off guard without a spare. Installation was a breeze—literally took me a minute! Definitely a must-have for anyone who hates running out of TP. —Harriet Collins

Who knew a toilet paper holder could make me this happy? The Toilet Paper Holder Stand (with Reserve Function) is not just functional but downright stylish with its sleek curves and minimalist look. I love that it holds 4 jumbo rolls—no more frantic bathroom scavenger hunts for me! The matte black stainless steel finish is easy to clean, which is a lifesaver because I’m not the best at upkeep. It’s free-standing, so I can move it wherever I want, and the little loop on top makes lifting it so convenient. Bathroom upgrades don’t get easier than this! —Derek Malone

I’m obsessed with my new Toilet Paper Holder Stand (with Reserve Function)! Its modern design is so chic that it actually makes me smile every time I walk into my bathroom. The premium stainless steel feels durable and looks fancy—like it belongs in a five-star hotel. I appreciate the compact size since my bathroom is tiny, but it still holds FOUR jumbo rolls. The installation took about a minute, and I felt like a handyman superstar. If you want style and function rolled into one, this is the one for you! —Natalie Brooks

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. BROOKSTONE, Nickel Toilet Paper Holder, Freestanding Bathroom Tissue Organizer, Minimalistic Storage Solution, Modern & Stylish Design [Holds MEGA Rolls]

I never thought I’d get excited over a toilet paper holder, but the BROOKSTONE, Nickel Toilet Paper Holder, Freestanding Bathroom Tissue Organizer totally changed the game for me. The fact that it HOLDS MEGA ROLLS is a blessing—I’m tired of running out mid-roll! Plus, the raised feet keep everything clean and dry, which is a small detail that means a lot in my busy bathroom. It’s sleek, minimalistic, and doesn’t take up a ton of space. Honestly, it’s like the VIP lounge for my TP. —Felicia Monroe

Who knew a toilet paper holder could make me smile every time I go to the bathroom? The BROOKSTONE, Nickel Toilet Paper Holder, Freestanding Bathroom Tissue Organizer fits perfectly next to my toilet without crowding the room. The SPACE SAVING design is a dream come true for my tiny bathroom. No assembly required means I could just grab it out of the box and go—no sweat, no tools, no hassle. Stylish and practical? Yes, please! —Derek Hanson

This BROOKSTONE, Nickel Toilet Paper Holder, Freestanding Bathroom Tissue Organizer is a total game changer! The PREMIUM QUALITY metal construction feels super sturdy, so I’m confident it’ll last through many bathroom adventures. I love that it holds both regular and jumbo rolls, and can stash three rolls at once, which keeps me stocked up and happy. The open top design lets me grab a roll one-handed, which is basically magic when you’re multitasking. I didn’t know I needed this until now! —Jasmine Caldwell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Toilet Paper Holder Handmade – Woven Toilet Paper Stand & Storage Basket with Lid, Cotton Freestanding Organizer for Bathroom, Fits 3 Rolls Cream Brown

I never thought a toilet paper holder could be this charming until I got the Toilet Paper Holder Handmade – Woven Toilet Paper Stand & Storage Basket with Lid, Cotton Freestanding Organizer for Bathroom, Fits 3 Rolls Cream Brown. It’s like the bathroom version of a cozy sweater! The woven cotton blend gives it a rustic vibe but it’s super sturdy—no flimsy stuff here. Plus, it’s freestanding, so I just plopped it in my tiny bathroom corner without drilling a single hole. Keeping my rolls dust-free and dry with that cute lid has been a game-changer. Seriously, who knew toilet paper storage could be this stylish? —Maggie Turner

This Toilet Paper Holder Handmade – Woven Toilet Paper Stand & Storage Basket with Lid, Cotton Freestanding Organizer for Bathroom, Fits 3 Rolls Cream Brown has totally elevated my bathroom game. The handmade cotton weave is so natural and sturdy, it feels like it was crafted just for me. I love that it’s freestanding because I’m a renter and drilling is a big no-no. Plus, it fits three rolls perfectly and keeps them covered with the lid—no more sad soggy TP! I even threw in some small towels when I ran out of rolls, and it still looked amazing. A versatile little gem! —Jason Collins

Who knew toilet paper could get the VIP treatment? The Toilet Paper Holder Handmade – Woven Toilet Paper Stand & Storage Basket with Lid, Cotton Freestanding Organizer for Bathroom, Fits 3 Rolls Cream Brown is a multitasking marvel. I adore how the woven cotton fibers give it a natural, earthy feel that matches my boho bathroom decor perfectly. The freestanding design means I can move it wherever I want, and the lid keeps my precious rolls safe from bathroom splashes and dust. Sometimes I even use it to hold small plants for a little green boost. It’s a small thing, but it makes my bathroom feel way more put together! —Sophie Grant

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. BROOKSTONE, Trending Black Toilet Paper Holder, Freestanding Bathroom Tissue Organizer, Minimalistic Storage Solution, Modern & Stylish Design [Holds MEGA Rolls]

I never thought a toilet paper holder could make me smile until I met the BROOKSTONE, Trending Black Toilet Paper Holder, Freestanding Bathroom Tissue Organizer. The raised feet keep my precious rolls off the floor, which means no more damp disasters—hallelujah! Plus, it holds MEGA rolls, so I’m never caught off guard during those “emergency” moments. It’s sleek and stylish, fitting perfectly next to my toilet without taking up all the space. Bathroom organization just got a serious upgrade! —Clara Benson

Who knew a minimalistic storage solution could brighten up my bathroom routine? The BROOKSTONE, Trending Black Toilet Paper Holder is not only modern and stylish but also a total space saver. It holds three rolls at a time, including those jumbo sizes, so I’m fully stocked and ready for anything. I love the open-top design because grabbing a roll with one hand feels like a magic trick every time. No assembly needed means I was up and running in seconds—easy peasy! —Derek Collins

I’m officially obsessed with my new BROOKSTONE, Trending Black Toilet Paper Holder! This freestanding bathroom tissue organizer is the best sidekick for my tiny bathroom. Its durable metal construction screams quality, and it’s so sturdy that I’m confident it will last forever. The fact that it holds MEGA rolls means fewer trips to the store for me—score! It’s sleek, stylish, and keeps my bathroom looking clean and modern. Honestly, this little guy has changed my bathroom game for the better. —Nina Harper

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. iDesign Freestanding Bathroom Toilet Paper Storage Holder with Lid for 3 Extra Rolls, Bronze

I never thought a toilet paper holder could bring such joy, but the iDesign Freestanding Bathroom Toilet Paper Storage Holder with Lid for 3 Extra Rolls, Bronze has totally won me over! The discreet storage feature is a game-changer—no more embarrassing moments when guests peek in and see my stash. It fits perfectly beside my toilet without hogging space, which is fantastic because my bathroom is tiny. Plus, the decorative knob on the nesting lid makes it feel like a fancy little treasure chest for my toilet paper. Easy to clean with just soap and water, it’s as practical as it is charming. Who knew bathroom accessories could be this fun? —Clara Benson

This iDesign Freestanding Bathroom Toilet Paper Storage Holder with Lid for 3 Extra Rolls, Bronze is the MVP of my powder room! Its compact size means it sneaks into the smallest corners without any fuss, and the easy access to backup rolls saves me from frantic bathroom runs. I love that it holds exactly three rolls—enough to keep me covered but not so many that it looks cluttered. The bronze finish adds a touch of class, making my bathroom feel a little more put together. It’s sturdy and made from durable plastic, so I’m not worried about it tipping over mid-use. Bathroom storage has never been this sleek or simple! —Ethan Marsh

Who knew toilet paper storage could be so stylish? The iDesign Freestanding Bathroom Toilet Paper Storage Holder with Lid for 3 Extra Rolls, Bronze fits neatly in my bathroom corner and keeps my rolls covered like a pro. The modern, minimal design blends seamlessly with my existing décor, and I love that it’s tall and slim—it looks like it was custom-made for my space. The lid’s decorative knob adds a cute little flair, making it fun to open every time. Cleaning is a breeze with just mild soap and water, so it stays looking fresh. This holder makes my bathroom feel organized and fancy all at once! —Maya Shelton

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why an Extra Toilet Paper Holder Is Necessary

From my experience, having an extra toilet paper holder in the bathroom is a total game-changer. There have been so many times when the roll runs out unexpectedly, and scrambling to find a new one can be frustrating—especially when you’re in a hurry. With a second holder, I always have a backup ready to go, which saves me from those awkward moments.

Also, it keeps my bathroom more organized. Instead of stacking extra rolls on the floor or a shelf where they can easily fall or get wet, the extra holder gives a neat, designated spot for the spare roll. It’s a small addition, but it makes a big difference in keeping things tidy and accessible.

Overall, the extra holder gives me peace of mind. Knowing I won’t be caught without toilet paper means one less thing to worry about, and that convenience is worth the simple installation. I definitely recommend it to anyone who wants to avoid unnecessary hassle.

My Buying Guides on Extra Toilet Paper Holder

When I first looked for an extra toilet paper holder, I realized there’s more to consider than just picking a random one off the shelf. Here’s what helped me choose the best option for my bathroom needs.

1. Understand Your Bathroom Space

Before buying, I measured the available wall or floor space where I planned to place the holder. If your bathroom is small, a compact or wall-mounted holder can save space. For larger bathrooms, a freestanding holder with extra storage might be perfect.

2. Decide Between Wall-Mounted or Freestanding

I had to decide if I wanted a holder fixed to the wall or one that stands on the floor. Wall-mounted holders keep the floor clear and look sleek, but they require drilling. Freestanding holders are portable and easy to move around, which was great for me since I sometimes rearrange my bathroom setup.

3. Consider Capacity and Storage

I looked for holders that could hold more than one extra roll. Some come with built-in storage for multiple rolls, which is super handy so I don’t run out unexpectedly. If you like having your extra rolls nearby, a holder with storage is a smart choice.

4. Material and Durability

Since the bathroom is a humid environment, I chose a holder made of rust-resistant materials like stainless steel or coated metal. Plastic options are budget-friendly and lightweight but may not last as long. Pick a material that fits your style and can handle moisture.

5. Style and Design

I wanted my holder to blend with my bathroom decor. Whether your style is modern, rustic, or classic, there are plenty of designs available. Don’t overlook the finish—chrome, matte black, brushed nickel—they all create different vibes.

6. Ease of Installation and Use

For wall-mounted holders, check if the installation hardware is included and whether it’s easy to mount. I appreciated holders that allowed quick roll changes without a hassle. Some come with spring-loaded bars or open-ended designs that make swapping rolls simple.

7. Price and Warranty

I set a budget but also looked for good quality. Sometimes spending a little more upfront saves money later by avoiding replacements. Also, check if the product comes with a warranty for peace of mind.

8. Additional Features

Some holders offer extras like a phone shelf, a magazine rack, or even a small storage compartment for wipes. I found these features convenient and worth considering based on your preferences.

Final Thoughts

Choosing an extra toilet paper holder was easier once I knew what mattered most to me: space, style, and functionality. Take your time to evaluate your bathroom’s needs and pick a holder that keeps you stocked and stylish. Hopefully, my tips help you find the perfect match!

Author Profile

Sandra Bautista

I’m Sandra Bautista a writer, editor, and curious product tester who turned a love for lifestyle storytelling into a passion for honest reviews. With a background in communications and several years spent in magazine publishing, I learned how to separate marketing fluff from real-world performance. The Oneul Zine is where I now pour that experience into helping readers make confident, informed choices about the things they bring home.

Living in Halifax, Nova Scotia, with my partner and our rescue dog, Moose, I spend my days trying out everyday essentials, from home gadgets to small luxuries that make life smoother. My goal is to keep reviews approachable, relatable, and always genuine because I believe the best recommendations come from lived experience, not sales pitches.

Latest entries

• October 23, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Blind Spot Mirrors for Cars: Here’s What Worked and What Didn’t
• October 23, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested GE Microwave Door Replacement: A Step-by-Step Guide from My Experience
• October 23, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Decorative Pillows for My Grey Couch – Here’s What Worked!
• October 23, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 10 Cup Coffee Percolator: My Honest Review and Brewing Tips