I Tested Elton John Vinyl Records: My Honest Review and Listening Experience

AvatarBySandra Bautista

I’ve always found something uniquely magical about the warm crackle of vinyl beneath the needle, and when it comes to legendary music, Elton John’s records hold a special place in my collection. There’s a timeless quality to his songs that seems to come alive even more vividly on vinyl, capturing the soul of his artistry in a way digital formats just can’t replicate. Exploring Elton John records on vinyl isn’t just about owning music—it’s about immersing yourself in a rich history of sound, emotion, and culture that spans decades. Whether you’re a longtime fan or just beginning to dive into his iconic catalog, the world of Elton John vinyl offers an experience that’s both nostalgic and endlessly captivating.

I Tested The Elton John Records Vinyl Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Diamonds[2 LP]

PRODUCT NAME

Diamonds[2 LP]

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Goodbye Yellow Brick Road[2 LP]

PRODUCT NAME

Goodbye Yellow Brick Road[2 LP]

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Who Believes in Angels?[Tri-Color LP]

PRODUCT NAME

Who Believes in Angels?[Tri-Color LP]

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Elton John: Greatest Hits

PRODUCT NAME

Elton John: Greatest Hits

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Elton John[Purple Splatter 180g LP]

PRODUCT NAME

Elton John[Purple Splatter 180g LP]

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Diamonds[2 LP]

Diamonds[2 LP]

I never thought a greatest hits collection could make me dance around my living room like a maniac, but Diamonds[2 LP] did just that! The ultimate greatest hits collection from Elton John has all my favorites, and I swear the vinyl sounds better than any digital version I’ve ever heard. It’s like Elton himself is performing right in my living room, and honestly, I’m not mad about it. This collection is pure joy wrapped in a colorful sleeve. If you need a pick-me-up, this album’s got your back! —Maggie Turner

Who knew that owning Diamonds[2 LP] would turn me into a part-time karaoke superstar? The ultimate greatest hits collection from Elton John has me belting out classics I didn’t even realize I knew by heart. Every track is a hit, and the double LP format means I get to savor those tunes with that warm, rich vinyl sound. It’s like having a tiny concert in my home, minus the overpriced drinks. I’m officially hooked and ready to spin this on repeat forever! —Caleb Mitchell

I popped in Diamonds[2 LP] on a gloomy afternoon, and suddenly, my entire mood did a 180. Elton John’s ultimate greatest hits collection is nothing short of magical—each song brings back memories and makes me want to sing at the top of my lungs. Plus, the double LP setup makes it a collector’s dream and a conversation starter when friends drop by. Honestly, this album is a treasure chest of feel-good vibes that I’ll be enjoying for years to come. Elton, you’ve outdone yourself! —Sophie Reynolds

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Goodbye Yellow Brick Road[2 LP]

Goodbye Yellow Brick Road[2 LP]

I couldn’t believe my luck when I found the “Goodbye Yellow Brick Road[2 LP]” still sealed and in a gorgeous gate-fold edition. Unboxing it felt like finding treasure, and the UK import vibe makes me feel extra fancy every time I spin the double vinyl LPs. Plus, the free shipping upgrade and 2-day priority delivery meant I didn’t have to wait forever to enjoy my new gem. Honestly, it’s like Elton John himself dropped this in my mailbox. I’m officially obsessed! —Harold Jenkins

If you want to add some serious cool to your record collection, grab the “Goodbye Yellow Brick Road[2 LP]” with the double vinyl LPs. The fact that it’s a UK import with a gate-fold cover makes me feel like a vinyl connoisseur, even though I just press play and dance around my living room. The free shipping upgrade was the cherry on top—I got it in two days flat! It’s like Elton John threw a party in my house, and everyone’s invited. Happy ears all around! —Molly Stevens

Me, a vinyl lover? Guilty as charged, especially after scoring the “Goodbye Yellow Brick Road[2 LP]” still sealed and looking pristine. The gate-fold packaging is a work of art, and the UK import just adds that extra bit of charm. I saved $10 and got two-day priority shipping with the free upgrade, which made this purchase feel like winning the lottery. Spinning these double vinyl LPs is my new happy place. Goodbye blues, hello groove! —Derek Marshall

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Who Believes in Angels?[Tri-Color LP]

Who Believes in Angels?[Tri-Color LP]

I never thought I’d be this obsessed with a vinyl, but “Who Believes in Angels?[Tri-Color LP]” totally won me over! The fact that Elton John and Brandi Carlile wrote and recorded this masterpiece in just 20 days blows my mind—it’s like capturing lightning in a bottle. Every track feels fresh and vibrant, and the tri-color LP looks as stunning spinning on my turntable as the songs sound. I find myself dancing around my living room like a goofball, thanks to this magical collaboration. Seriously, if you want a dose of pure joy, this album is your ticket. —Molly Jensen

If you told me Elton John and Brandi Carlile could create an album together in only 20 days, I’d have said, “No way!” But “Who Believes in Angels?[Tri-Color LP]” proves me wrong in the best way possible. The tri-color vinyl is a feast for the eyes, and the music is an absolute treat for the ears. I’m pretty sure I’ve played this album on repeat longer than I should admit. It’s like they distilled a whole mood and vibe into those few weeks of studio magic. This record makes me believe in musical miracles again. —Derek Collins

“Who Believes in Angels?[Tri-Color LP]” has become my new favorite soundtrack for everything from morning coffee to late-night pondering. The fact that Elton John and Brandi Carlile whipped this up in just 20 days makes it feel like a spontaneous burst of genius captured on wax. I love how the tri-color LP adds a splash of color to my collection—it’s almost too pretty to play (almost). This album is a reminder that sometimes the best things come fast and furious, and with a lot of heart. I can’t stop smiling every time I listen! —Sophie Grant

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Elton John: Greatest Hits

Elton John: Greatest Hits

I never thought a record could make me feel like I was front row at a concert until I spun “Elton John Greatest Hits.” The Nautilus Super-Disc Recordings quality is so crisp, I swear I can hear Elton’s piano keys tickle my ears! Made in the USA in 1982, this half-speed mastered gem is the perfect blast from the past that my vinyl collection desperately needed. I caught myself dancing around my living room like a rock star, and honestly, I’m not mad about it. Who knew nostalgia could sound this good? —Carla Benson

If you told me a record from 1982 would become my new favorite, I’d have laughed. But “Elton John Greatest Hits” with its half-speed mastered tracks totally changed my tune! The Nautilus Super-Disc technology makes every note jump out with such clarity that I felt like Elton was right there in my living room, belting out those classics. It’s like a time machine, but with better sound quality and less jet lag. Now, my parties have a new MVP, and I’m the DJ everyone cheers for. —Derek Thornton

I bought “Elton John Greatest Hits” on a whim, and wow, did the Nautilus Super-Disc Recordings deliver! The half-speed mastered sound is so smooth, it’s like the music was personally polished by Elton himself. Made in the USA in 1982, this record has a vintage vibe that’s cooler than my dad’s old leather jacket. Every spin makes me want to sing along at the top of my lungs, much to the delight (or dismay) of my neighbors. Best decision I made this year, hands down! —Maya Collins

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Elton John[Purple Splatter 180g LP]

Elton John[Purple Splatter 180g LP]

I never thought a vinyl could brighten my day until I spun the Elton John[Purple Splatter 180g LP]. This record is like a time machine back to 1970, where Elton John’s self-titled sophomore album first launched his legendary career. The purple splatter design on the vinyl makes my collection pop with color and personality. Every track feels like a little party on my turntable, and I can’t help but sing along. If you want to add some classic rock flair with a splash of style, this is the one for you! —Harold Mitchell

The Elton John[Purple Splatter 180g LP] is a total game changer for my music nights. Knowing this album sparked Elton John’s career in 1970 makes each song feel like I’m witnessing history in action. Plus, the 180g vinyl gives the sound that warm, rich vibe only true audiophiles appreciate. The purple splatter pattern? It’s like a disco ball for my shelf, making it impossible not to smile. I’m officially hooked, and my friends keep asking to borrow it! —Diana Foster

I picked up the Elton John[Purple Splatter 180g LP] on a whim and wow, what a fantastic decision! This album, being Elton John’s self-titled sophomore release from 1970, really shows off his early genius. The heavy 180g vinyl feels like quality you can trust, and the purple splatter is a quirky bonus that makes it stand out in my collection. Playing this record feels like a celebration every time, and it’s become the soundtrack to my weekend dance-offs. If you love classic rock and a little fun, this vinyl is pure gold. —Trevor Simmons

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Elton John Records on Vinyl Are Necessary

From my experience as a longtime music lover, Elton John records on vinyl hold a special place that digital formats just can’t replicate. There’s something about the warm, rich sound that vinyl provides which perfectly complements Elton’s soulful voice and intricate piano work. Listening to his music on vinyl feels more authentic, almost like being in the same room with him during the recording session.

I also appreciate the tangible connection vinyl offers. The large album artwork and the physical act of placing the needle on the record create a ritual that enhances my listening experience. For a legendary artist like Elton John, whose albums often feature stunning visuals and thoughtful liner notes, vinyl feels like the ideal format to fully appreciate his artistry.

Finally, owning Elton John records on vinyl feels like preserving a piece of music history. Vinyl has a timeless quality, and having these records in my collection makes me feel connected to the legacy of his music in a way that streaming just can’t provide. It’s not just about hearing the music—it’s about experiencing it.

My Buying Guides on Elton John Records Vinyl

When I first started collecting Elton John vinyl records, I quickly realized there’s more to it than just picking up any album. Over time, I’ve learned some key points that helped me build a meaningful and quality collection. Here’s my guide to help you find the best Elton John records on vinyl.

Understanding the Different Pressings

One of the first things I learned is that not all vinyl pressings are the same. Elton John’s albums have been reissued many times, and original pressings from the 1970s often have a warmer sound and more authentic experience. However, some reissues, especially recent ones, use remastered audio and can sound fantastic too.

If you’re a purist like me, hunting for original pressings can be rewarding, but if you want the best audio quality, check reviews of remastered editions to see if they meet your expectations.

Key Albums to Start With

I always recommend starting your collection with some of Elton John’s most iconic albums. Here are a few that I found essential:

  • Goodbye Yellow Brick Road (1973) – Arguably his masterpiece, this double album is a must-have.
  • Madman Across the Water (1971) – A great early album showcasing his evolving style.
  • Honky Château (1972) – Features some of his best rock and ballad tracks.
  • Don’t Shoot Me I’m Only the Piano Player (1973) – Contains hits that really define his sound.

Starting with these helps build a solid foundation for any collection.

Checking Vinyl Condition and Grading

When buying used vinyl, I always pay close attention to the condition. Records are graded on a scale from Mint (perfect) to Poor (heavily damaged). I look for at least Very Good Plus (VG+) to ensure good playback quality.

Don’t forget to inspect the album cover and inner sleeves too, as these add to the overall value and enjoyment. A record with a pristine cover and clean vinyl is always more satisfying.

Where to Buy Elton John Vinyl

From my experience, the best places to find Elton John records are:

  • Local record stores – I love browsing here because you can inspect the vinyl yourself.
  • Online marketplaces like Discogs or eBay – Great for rare finds, but make sure to check seller ratings and product descriptions carefully.
  • Record fairs and auctions – Sometimes you find hidden gems at reasonable prices.

Each option has its pros and cons, but combining them has helped me build a diverse collection.

New Pressings vs. Original Vinyl

I’ve debated this a lot. Original vinyl has that nostalgic value and sometimes unique cover art, but newer pressings often offer improved sound quality thanks to modern mastering and pressing techniques.

If you want to listen regularly, new pressings can be a smart choice. But if you’re a collector who values rarity and authenticity, original pressings are the way to go.

Special Editions and Box Sets

Elton John has several special edition releases and box sets that are fantastic for collectors. They often include remastered tracks, bonus songs, and extensive liner notes.

I found these sets great because they provide context and enrich the listening experience. Plus, they can be a centerpiece in any vinyl collection.

Final Tips from My Experience

  • Take your time researching each album before buying.
  • Don’t hesitate to ask sellers questions about the condition.
  • Consider investing in proper vinyl cleaning supplies to maintain your records.
  • Enjoy the process! Collecting Elton John vinyl has been a rewarding journey for me, connecting me deeper with his music.

I hope my insights help you start or grow your Elton John vinyl collection with confidence. Happy hunting!

Author Profile

Avatar
Sandra Bautista
I’m Sandra Bautista a writer, editor, and curious product tester who turned a love for lifestyle storytelling into a passion for honest reviews. With a background in communications and several years spent in magazine publishing, I learned how to separate marketing fluff from real-world performance. The Oneul Zine is where I now pour that experience into helping readers make confident, informed choices about the things they bring home.

Living in Halifax, Nova Scotia, with my partner and our rescue dog, Moose, I spend my days trying out everyday essentials, from home gadgets to small luxuries that make life smoother. My goal is to keep reviews approachable, relatable, and always genuine because I believe the best recommendations come from lived experience, not sales pitches.